top of page

How can Christians Know the Right Time to Make Dating Exclusive?

Feb 20, 2025
6 min read

Updated: Feb 22, 2025

The right time to make dating exclusive


Is it okay for Christians to date multiple people at the same time?


If so, at what point in a developing relationship should Christian dating become exclusive?


Full transparency – the fact that this is even a question baffles me.


My two cents: Christian singles would do best to not date at all until they are ready to find a spouse, and then get to know only one person at a time, comparing that person to the criteria they have predetermined would best fit their life, rather than comparing them to other people they are seeing.


I’ve seen relationship coaches online…supposedly Christian relationship coaches, teaching that it is okay, even desirable, to date multiple people at once.



Podcasters a social media influencers
I heard it on the interwebs, so it must be true.


Some of their arguments go something like this:


  1. You want to keep your options open until you know you are ready to be exclusive and settle down.


  1. By dating multiple people we can get a sense of different personalities and see what works best for us.


  1. Becoming exclusive too soon can send the wrong message, and make us seem desperate, or advance the relationship faster than we would like it to progress. We don’t want things to spiral out of our control, so it is good to date around.


  1. Exclusivity can hint at expectations of marriage, which can stress some people out. Not every dating experience needs to lead to marriage, keeping it fun and casual at first can help reduce stress and make dating in general a positive experience.


To all of that I would like to say, “Hogwash!”


Is there anything wrong with Christians dating multiple people?


Keeping dating casual, and non-exclusive, ranks up there in the top 5 of the most irresponsible pieces of dating advice I have ever heard anyone spew, let alone Christians.


It’s right up there with ideas like “learning to love yourself before you can truly love anyone else”, “the top ___ signs you’ve found your soulmate”, and “how to find your Boaz (or Ruth)”.


Don’t get me wrong, I believe that most of the people who spout these monumentally bad ideas may be genuine in their desire to help people. Unfortunately, their views have been informed more by pop-culture than by the Bible, psychology, or reason.


Let’s analyze each of the 4 arguments for dating multiple people listed above, to see why the whole idea is ill-conceived.


  1. Keep your options open until you know you are ready to be exclusive


For a Christian, what is the purpose of dating?


Other than those who think dating is just something fun to do, most believers would argue that it is a socially acceptable means of vetting a potential spouse.


If one is not yet ready for marriage, why bother dating?


Getting your heart entangled with another heart is no small issue.


It is nearly impossible for any two people to date for any length of time without at least one of them developing some sort of feelings. Then when the person with less feelings breaks off the “casual” relationship, at least one party is heartbroken; they’ve had their head messed with; they start to get a jaded view of relationships; and the list goes on.


If you are prepared to endure an endless string of disappointment and heartache, then by all means, just date for the fun of it. If you feel that you are not affected by such things, and so are willing to risk a string of exes who are disappointed and heartbroken in your wake, then you should really rethink whether you should be dating at all in the first place.


That doesn’t seem to me to be a Christ-centered attitude towards fellow believers.


As much as it absolutely sucks to hear, it is best to stay single and work on your relationship with God, work on your life, and develop a plan until you are at the point in your life where you are ready to be married; and then go looking for someone to build a life-long love with.


  1. Getting a sense of different personalities


If you’re keeping things casual so you can check out different personalities, just go read the DSM-5, or take some psychology classes.



Multiple personalities
They're with me, not you!


If you need to date different people so you can mentally frankenstein what an ideal spouse would be for you there are several things wrong:


A) You will end up disillusioned and unable to find your ideal because no one person will ever be able to meet all your expectations.


B) Probably most important, you don’t really know yourself well enough to give reasonable and intelligent consideration to what works best for you and your situation.


C) You likely do not have a great sense of who you are in God and are trying to fill a void with attention and validation.


When your relationship with God is on point and growing, your motivation for relationships shift from being primarily focused on your needs to being focused on what you can do for others.


When God is the center and anchor for your life, he fills the emotional void, and then you can think clearly and create a plan for your life and the type of person who would fit well within that plan.


  1. Maintain control and do not seem desperate


Anyone who needs to date multiple people to maintain the illusion of having control of their life, and of the multiple relationships they are in, is already showing their desperation.


Forget all the nonsense about the “Alpha” and about exuding confidence, and maintaining control of a situation. Real confidence comes from the self-discipline of maintaining singleness until ready for marriage; growing in God; developing life skills, finances, education, etc.


No one has ever (EVER) regretted a life of self-discipline and development. Then when you decide you are ready to look for a spouse it is much easier to find someone because you are not bothered by everyone who crosses your path. You have narrowed your idea of what a spouse should be down to the type of person who will fit well with the life you have developed, and continue to develop.


  1. Keeping things casual reduces stress


Keeping things casual reduces stress?


Really?!


Really?


What is more stressful, calling the 3-4 people who are on your roster at any given time to see who might be available for a date Friday night, or calling the 1 person you are in a relationship with to make a for-sure plan for Friday night?


Is it better trying to keep names straight? Is it better fretting over buying multiple gifts for multiple people for multiple birthdays and occasions? Is it better showing up to a function with one person you are dating, and then bumping into someone else you were on a date with just last week (or last night)?


Or, does it sound better to just have to remember one name; remember one birthday; have one person you know you can rely on for a plus one for all occasions?


Even so-called Christian relationship coaches, teachers, and yes, even some pastors can dispense crappy advice out of a sincere heart.


So how can I discern good advice from bad advice?



Decision making
Yes, no, maybe?

When you hear someone dispensing advice I suggest asking yourself 4 questions:


  1. Is it Biblical?


  1. Is it rational?


  1. If I do what they are saying, what are some of the natural consequences that may occur as a result?


  1. Will the result likely be a benefit or a detriment to me or to others and their walk with God?


I’m not here to tell you what you must do.


I’m just hoping to get people thinking rationally about all the advice they hear floating around out there rather than allowing themselves to be swayed by something that plays into their ego and emotions.


What do you think -- when is the right time to make dating exclusive?


And...


What answers would you come up with if you apply the 4 questions above to the idea of dating multiple people at the same time?


I trust you’ve found today’s topic helpful, and I’d love to hear your feedback, and your questions. Connect



in the comments, or via email: info@redesignyourtruelove.com.

Comments


© 2023 by Regular Dad's Life.

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
bottom of page