top of page

How to Write Your Ultimate Dating Profile

Feb 10, 2025
7 min read

The Problem With Most Profiles


Why do we try to make ourselves sound like such a great catch to absolutely everyone when we create an online dating profile?



Woman using cellphone
Trust me, you ain't never met anyone like me.


The idea of pulling multiple people is enticing for many of us because we want to believe we can have our pick of the lot.


So, we tend to cast as wide a net as possible. We highlight our strengths, downplay or completely leave out our weaknesses, and try to make ourselves sound as enticing as we can by presenting a laid-back, serious, vulnerable, strong, emotional, stoic persona.


I get it.


We want to feel like we are so awesome that anyone and everyone would be lucky to have us. Who wouldn’t want the confidence boost that comes from opening the app to see multiple people have swiped right on our profile? And, having multiple options to choose from can make us feel like we are in control. It should be easy to find a spouse; we just have to sort through the pile of potentials until we find that special someone…right?


If that is the case why haven’t more of us found our ideal mate through online dating?


Choice Overload


The idea of multiple options sounds great, but in reality, it can lead to choice overload. Yes, this is a real thing, not just some idea I made up.


Chip aisle at grocery store
What do you mean I can only pick one?

Choice overload happens when we have too many options to choose from. We can experience mental fatigue from constantly having to weed out unwanted options. It can cause us to shut down mentally and avoid making any decisions.


Have you ever gotten fed up with dating, and said you were going to stop it altogether?


Or maybe you didn’t swear off the search completely, but decided to take a break from dating for a while.


That is a result of choice overload.


Or does it seem like you keep repeating relationship patterns; and you seem to meet the same person over and over, just in a different body?


This too is a result of choice overload.


We have so many options, and our brain is so tired of having to make so many decisions in our day-to-day life – so whenever possible it shifts to neutral, and we subconsciously pick the default option…the thing we most familiar with. Our brain likes things that are familiar because it requires less mental energy to evaluate and pick.


The twisted thing here is, even if we know something might not be good for us, our brain finds emotional comfort in the idea of the familiar. The unfamiliar can cause anxiety, so we go with what we know.


Well then, how do we break out of the mental fatigue of choice overload when it comes to online dating?


Solution: Create Your Ultimate Dating Profile


Stop trying to make ourselves sound like a great catch to everyone, and instead go “fishing” with a specific bait, designed to attract a specific catch.


Let’s create our ultimate dating profile by taking a page from the business world and write our Dating Elevator Pitch.


In business, the purpose of an elevator pitch is to get the right people (ideal client) to opt in and the wrong people to opt out quickly. It is a tool to weed out all the "nos" as fast as possible so you can get to the "yeses" with the people who will genuinely value the service or product you offer.


In the business world, the basic structure of an elevator pitch has four main parts:


  1. Identify need


  1. Distill the need and flip into a promise of benefit for the ideal client


  1. State the solution that will be delivered (product or service) and how it ultimately benefits ideal client


  1. How can it be used?


Here is a generic summary statement that could be used as the formula when talking to potential clients: "Some people are plagued by problem X (the need). We can help those people experience freedom (the benefit) from X by using our solution (product or service). It can be used in these 3 ways, and can lead to ________ benefits.”


Now, let's adapt that to a dating profile, while looking back to the basic structure of an elevator pitch.


As we do this little exercise together, keep in mind this is just one example. If you decide to use this idea, you'll need to customize it to fit your unique situation.


Okay, here we go:


  1. Identify a need: There seems to be a lack of suitable, genuine Christian partners.


  1. Distill the need and flip into a promise of benefit for the ideal client: Looking for a spouse to grow in faith together, committed to the marriage, and raising children in the Word".


  1. State what solution we deliver (product or service) and how it ultimately benefits the ideal client: “I am a Christian man (or woman), on a mission to do ________ (state a life mission or major life goal).....”


  1. How can it be used? “….looking to develop a serious relationship with a solid Christian woman (or man), leading to a marriage where we will ………”


Man texting on phone
"Please swipe right, please swipe right..."

So now, let’s rewrite the generic summary statement, but this time filling in the blanks to make it specific. The example below is based upon a hypothetical man writing the profile.


Despite what seems to be a lack of genuine Christians in online apps, I have faith that an authentic Christian woman is out there who is grounded in her faith; has God as the source of her love; will be happy to come with me to church each week; help raise our children in the Word; be supportive of my medical training, and calling to serve in the military; and knows the meaning of ‘til-death-do-us-part.


For the profile above profile:


  1. Problem – lack of genuine Christian suitors


  1. Problem distilled and flipped – basically states “I am a genuine Christian who’s looking to meet a wife and lead a family in the ways of God”.


  1. Solution and how it can be used are intertwined in the profile – “life-long commitment, leading family to church and growing in faith, providing for family by becoming a doctor and specifically looking to serve in the military”.


Some people may feel that this example sounds a little too heavy, or that our guy is coming on a little strong. They may be thinking, “let’s keep things a bit lighter when starting out, and then let seriousness develop as the relationship grows”.


Consider this: where a more generic profile may get up to 20 swipe rights each month, the profile that’s specific may only get 1 or 2…and that’s a good thing.


Assuming average looks (and accurate photos), the fewer swipe rights a profile gets, the more likely that those who did swipe right are a close match to what you might be looking for.


Back to the hypothetical profile we just wrote. If our guy had written “looking to have fun with someone, with potential for long term”, he may get numerous swipe rights and end up in the initial messaging stage with up to 20 people throughout the year.


Of those messaging stages, let’s say 10 could lead to an initial date.


Of those 10, let’s say that at least 5 make it past the first date.


Of those 5, it is very possible that none of them are quite what our guy is looking for…simply because he cast too wide a net.


However, when he uses his dating elevator pitch as an opener, he then has a guide for writing the rest of his profile (simply elaborate a little on each aspect of the DEP).


Now armed with his ultimate dating profile, let’s say he has attracted 6 - 8 swipe rights throughout the year.


Of the swipe rights, let’s say 7 make it to the messaging stage.


Of those messaging stages, let’s say 5 make it to a first date.


Of the first dates, at least 3 could make it beyond the first date.


Of those 3, there is a decent chance that at least 1 of them is the type of person our guy is looking for.


Why?


Because from day one, the women swiping right know exactly what our guy’s life is about, how serious he is about his faith, and the plan he has for his future and the future of his family. There’s no surprises.


The person with a net will have to take the time to pick out all kinds of things they don’t want and throw it back into the water. The person with a single line and the correct lure/bait may only catch 1 fish, but it will be the exact type of fish they want.


So create your ultimate dating profile by being as specific as possible when putting yourself out there on an app.


Author’s Note:


As a general rule, I do not give much credibility to online dating apps.


They’re specifically designed to make money. They do not make this money by immediately matching people up with a great potential partner. They make their money by designing algorithms that will keep people on the app and swiping for as long as possible.


Sure, most apps have a free version, but they have some major drawbacks:


  1. The free version will usually only show you people which the app feels are the most physically attractive.


  1. The apps almost never match you with someone who would be a potential fit while you are using the free version.


  1. Each app will have their most helpful features hidden behind a paywall


Even if you use the paid version of the apps, there are several other ways of meeting people which carry a statistically higher chance of finding a spouse.


Of course there are exceptions, and I know people who have actually met their spouse online, and are happily married. So Your Ultimate Dating Profile was written to help Christians have the best possible shot at meeting someone via a dating app.


I trust you’ve found today’s topic helpful, and I’d love to hear your feedback, and your questions. Connect in the comments, or via email: info@redesignyourtruelove.com.

Comments


© 2023 by Regular Dad's Life.

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
bottom of page